Uploaded image for project: 'XJDF / JDF'
  1. XJDF / JDF
  2. JDF-573

Cardinality of measurements in QualityControlResult

    XMLWordPrintable

    Details

    • Draft:
      Hide

      6.69 QualityControlResult
      QualityControlResult defines the set of results from a QualityControl process. The specific measurements should be returned
      in one of the specialized subelements such as BindingQualityMeasurement or as a subelements of the parent Resource that are
      in a foreign namespace. QualityControl results may also be referenced by providing a FileSpec that references a proprietary
      measurement results definition. Examples for quality control measurements in a foreign namespace include
      [ISO17972-1:2015] for color measurement data.
      Each individual measurement that is reported as a specific subelement should reside in a unique Resource element with Resource/Part/@QualityMeasurement specified and unique. The method of summarizing multiple measurements to an average value is system dependent and MAY be dictated by an ICS.

      Table 6.148: QualityControlResult Resource

      Measurements ? ... @Measurements SHALL specify the Total number of measurements and SHOULD be provided in the context of ResourceInfo If the value of @Measurements is >1 any speciffic measurement subelement SHOULD be an average measurement. The method of summarizing multiple measurements to an average value is system dependent.
      BindingQualityMeasurement * .. Individual measurement results of binding quality. BindingQualityMeasurement SHALL define the details of an individual or average binding quality measurement. Not more than one BindingQualityMeasurement SHOULD be specified.
      Note the cardinality of multiple measurements is retained for backwards compatibility only.
      RegistrationQuality
      *?...
      ... Each RegistrationQuality SHALL define the details of anindividual or average color registration measurement.
      Show
      6.69 QualityControlResult QualityControlResult defines the set of results from a QualityControl process. The specific measurements should be returned in one of the specialized subelements such as BindingQualityMeasurement or as a subelement s of the parent Resource that are in a foreign namespace. QualityControl results may also be referenced by providing a FileSpec that references a proprietary measurement results definition. Examples for quality control measurements in a foreign namespace include  [ISO17972-1:2015] for color measurement data. Each individual measurement that is reported as a specific subelement should reside in a unique Resource element with Resource/Part/@QualityMeasurement specified and unique. The method of summarizing multiple measurements to an average value is system dependent and MAY be dictated by an ICS. Table 6.148: QualityControlResult Resource Measurements ? ... @Measurements SHALL specify the Total number of measurements and SHOULD be provided in the context of ResourceInfo If the value of @Measurements is >1 any speciffic measurement subelement SHOULD be an average measurement. The method of summarizing multiple measurements to an average value is system dependent. BindingQualityMeasurement * .. Individual measurement results of binding quality . BindingQualityMeasurement SHALL define the details of an individual or average binding quality measurement. Not more than one BindingQualityMeasurement SHOULD be specified. Note the cardinality of multiple measurements is retained for backwards compatibility only. RegistrationQuality * ? ... ... Each RegistrationQuality SHALL define the details of an individual or average color registration measurement.

      Description

      we currently allow a set of detailed measurements in QualityControlResult

      Advantage:

      • short and concise.
      • We have a concept of "measurement set"
        Disadvantages:
      • An implementation can choose to provide N QualityControlResult elements with 1 detailed measurement or 1 QualityControlResult with n detailed measurements.
      • Only the set of measurements has a time range and scope
        Should we only allow one measurement / QualityControlResult?

        Attachments

          Issue Links

            Activity

              People

              • Assignee:
                Unassigned
                Reporter:
                prosi Rainer Prosi
              • Votes:
                0 Vote for this issue
                Watchers:
                3 Start watching this issue

                Dates

                • Created:
                  Updated:
                  Resolved: